Tony Awards 2025 update and tidbits: Am I disappointed Audra McDonald didn’t win a 7th Tony? Sure, a little.
By Donald Munro
She didn’t win: I’m disappointed that Audra McDonald didn’t win her seventh Tony Award. I’m biased, of course. but this is one of those times when cultural lovers intersect with hometown sports fans. I don’t care that I didn’t see any of the nominated performances or that Audra already has six Tonys to dust. When she’s nominated, she’s my favorite.
“A pin drop”: That’s how the New York Times described the audience’s rapt attention during Audra’s stunning performance of “Rose’s Turn” in her big Tony moment. I had read a lot about this pivotal moment in the show, and I interviewed some very astute people who helped analyze why it is a major moment in Broadway history, but all the research couldn’t truly prepare me for the raw, visceral, potent presence of Audra on stage. I felt like I was in the room with her, and I felt a connection as complete as if were both hooked up to the same throbbing, electrical current. If felt like more than acting — as if she caused a momentary disturbance in the socio-emotional norms of theater itself. It was stunning.
Getty Images for Tony Awards Productions Audra McDonald performs a number from “Gypsy” onstage during The 78th Annual Tony Awards at Radio City Music Hall on June 08, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by Theo Wargo/Getty Images for Tony Awards Productions)
Afterward: As my friend Stephen Mintz asks: “Did you see Audra walk off the stage? Head sagging and tremors remaining from the deep emotion of that performance. Audra didn’t care about singing well. She was Mama Rose and ran through the gamut of the emotional swings.” I completely agree. Whereas other performers put on happy Tony-nominee faces as they walked offstage and immediately played the roles of grateful actor, Audra wasn’t able to wrench herself out of that intense place she’d just gone for us. She was still shifting back to herself, so to speak. She was that invested in her performance.
Related story: Will Tony voters bestow a 7th Tony Award on Fresno’s Audra McDonald? No one knows for sure, but these four local admirers are rooting for her.
The Tony goes to: Nicole Scherzinger also gave a strong live performance from “Sunset Blvd.” (and she would go on to win the Tony for the role), but Scherzinger seemed overly mannered to me — more like beautifully performed calisthenics than a soul-baring moment. When Audra didn’t win, I like to think there was a bit of regret in the hall. How could the Tony voters ignore that performance?
Speaking of: I think that if the Patti LuPone silliness — and, completely unrelated, the Time magazine cover proclaiming Audra as “Broadway’s Greatest” — had happened a few weeks earlier, when I’m assuming that Tony voting was still going strong, I think the outcome could have been different.
STORY CONTINUES AFTER SPONSORED CONTENT
But: Audra gave it her all. Even though she didn’t win, her chance to perform “Rose’s Turn” in front of a national television audience was perhaps the best thing to come out of the Tony experience. If you could hear a pin drop in the hall during her performance, I can imagine much the same happened in many living rooms: people stopping their double-tasking or bitchy conversations (this is a theater crowd, after all) and sticking their eyes to the screen. It was that kind of moment.
Which reminds me: Why isn’t Audra a household name, at least in her hometown? Several friends posed that question to me over the past few weeks as the Tony race heated up. For me, the answer is sadly simple: Theater is niche. If Audra were a Super Bowl-winning linebacker, we’d probably have a parade after each of her accomplishments.
The Munro Review has no paywall but is financially supported by readers who believe in its non-profit mission of bringing professional arts journalism to the central San Joaquin Valley. You can help by signing up for a monthly recurring paid membership or make a one-time donation of as little as $3. All memberships and donations are tax-deductible. The Munro Review is funded in part by the City of Fresno Measure P Expanded Access to Arts and Culture Fund administered by the Fresno Arts Council.
Marketing possibility: But what if Fresno were more proactive in terms of promoting its Broadway royalty? (It’d be nice, for a start, for local media to bother covering something like Audra’s chance at a seventh Tony win. The closest The Bee got was a syndicated column about the LuPone incident. Oh, and it ran a story on Sunday headlined “Vehicle crashes into pole in front of Roosevelt High, causing power outage, police say,” a nod to Audra’s school.) How about a giant mural of Audra? A billboard campaign? An Audra walking tour? Hey, arts community, let’s put our collective heads together.
Steph
She deserves parades. All she has is a street.
I thought Sherzinger’s performance came more from wide-armed choreography rather than thoroughly internal manifestation.
Did you see Audra walk off the stage? Head sagging and tremors remaining from the deep emotion of that performance. Audra didn’t care about singing well. She was Mama Rose and ran through the gamut of the emotional swings.
I agreed with your post prior to the awards that they’d likely want to spread the love, but after seeing Audra??? She deserved the 7th all day long.
And that emotional journey after performing a matinee!
A parade indeed. With Dan Pessano sitting up front with her.
pumice-boat-ovary@duck.com
Clearly, she didn’t care about singing well as she did not by any measure. A live abomination from an overrated critics’ darling. Oh, but she can ACT, the go-to excuse that’s been trotted out since the show’s opening to dismiss her inability to deliver the vocal goods. The role is a bad fit and she knows it—hence the frenetic pushing, posturing, and screaming. In no world did she deserve a Tony for this vanity project gone wrong.
And once and for all, can we stop w/the “Mama” Rose? At no point in the script is she referred to as that. It’s “Madame” Rose.
Steph
Something I just thought of – While Audra did it the best, we can’t forget the legends that are Patti Lupone and Bernadette Peters also played the same role on Broadway. Older Tony voters wouldn’t want to single out Audra from those luminaries…especially with the current ladies who lunch gossip going on.
Another mention – the best performance of Mama Rose I ever saw live and in person was another stage legend, Ms Clytee Ramsey. When she hit that final minor key note in Rose’s Turn I was transformed.