Theater Review: Ten things to like about an eminently likable “Annie”
By Doug Hoagland
Musical theaterโs favorite red-haired moppet and her besties at the orphanage have returned to a Fresno stage in the capable hands of Good Company Players.
Now at Roger Rockaโs Dinner Theater through Sept. 20, โAnnieโ is familiar and comfortable. The title character dreams about โTomorrow.โ Miss Hannigan and her neโer-do-well brother, Rooster, crow about โEasy Street.โ Oliver Warbucks pays tribute to his hometown, โNYC.โ
When the show debuted on Broadway in 1977, The New York Timesโhome of serious theater criticismโdeclared the show to be eminently likable. Actually, The Times suggested that to dislike โAnnieโ was โtantamount to disliking motherhood, peanut butter, friendly mongrel dogs and nostalgia.โ

With that marker thrown down, here are 10 things to like (in no particular order) about the current GCP production directed by Haleigh Cook and Steve Souza. Both are talented performers; Souza has directed before; โAnnieโ is Cookโs directorial debut.
ONE: Sonora Warkentin is a wonderfully natural Annie, and she gives an honest and authentic performance. Her singing is crystal clear, and her dancing is graceful. (She alternates the role with Campbell Sloas; I attended on a night when Sonora performed.)
TWO: A strong, talented ensemble never loses momentum in propelling the narrative forward. Special shoutout to Mitchell Ralston as the butler, Drake, for mining humor in a role that suggests stuffiness.
THREE: The showโs furry, four-legged performers are ready for their closeups. Two dogs alternate as Sandy, the pooch that Annie befriends. The dogs are Oatmeal, a 1-year-old Goldendoodle, and Honey, a 4-year-old Labrador Retriever.
Oatmeal is reportedly something of a ham. His doggie mom, Mia Moore, asks him on performance nights, “Are you ready to do your show?โ and he bounds to the front door. Moore and Oatmealโs doggie daddy, Zachary Kelley, have both acted at GCP. โSo Oatmealโs talent really does run in the family,โ Moore said.
Honey also enjoys performing. โHer favorite thing in the world is kids, and it gives her a lot of life spending time with the kids in the cast,โ said Taylor Herbert, Honeyโs doggie mom.Oatmeal and Honey have met, and their time together is best described as โchaotic,โ Herbert said with a laugh. Oatmeal is something of a fan boy. โHe looks up to Honey,โ Moore said.

FOUR: โAnnieโsโ first act showstopper, โEasy Street,โ arrives courtesy of Miss Hannigan (a wonderful Camille Gaston), Rooster (a charismatic Khari Somerville) and Lily St. Regis (Emily Kearns, doing much with a small part). Their singing and dancing are exuberant, but thatโs only the beginning of what sells the number. Thereโs a playfulness in their shenanigans thatโs palpable.
FIVE: More about Gaston: She delivers the kind of strong performance that Valley audiences have come to expect. Gaston employs a powerful voice, comedic chops and finely-tuned timing to good effect. Hannigan is written to be broadly played, but Gaston keeps her a character, not a caricature.

SIX: Daniel Sutherland brings his resonant baritone to the role of Warbucks. In โI Donโt Need Anything But Youโโa duet with AnnieโSutherland conveys an emotional warmth thatโs among many genuine moments in the production.
SEVEN: โAnnieโ is no โHamiltonโ when it comes to American history. But it acknowledges a real part of the Depression: In the 1930s, people who had lost everything huddled in make-shift shanty settlements known as Hoovervilles. They were derisively named for President Herbert Hoover, and the ensemble confirms that fact with biting sarcasm in the song, โWeโd Like To Thank You, Herbert Hoover.โ
EIGHT: Costume designer Ginger Kay Lewis-Reed captures the hard times of โAnnieโsโ Depression-era setting with vintage clothing. Miss Hannigan wears a long, black silk kimono from the 1920s. The folks in Hooverville have moth-eaten sweaters, overcoats with missing pockets and beat-up hatsโall decades old. Some of the vintage clothing came through donations.
Thereโs GCP history in the outfits worn by Warbucksโ secretary, Grace Farrell (Amalie Larsen). Larsen wears a caped suit, a tricolored coat with fox trim and a silk velvet party dress designed and made by Chris Moad, one of GCPโs founders. He produced the outfits for GCPโs first production of โAnnieโ in 1983. Lewis-Reed was Moadโs assistant and helped sew the outfits. โChris was my mentor, a great designer and a pleasure to work with,โ she said.
NINE: Speaking of Larsen: She conveys Farrellโs efficiency without shedding the characterโs humanity, and also shows emotional warmth without lapsing into sentimentality. Itโs a smooth and polished performance.

TEN: โAnnieโsโ cast includes younger performers working their way to a bigger place in the spotlight. One example: Izsac Valencia as the fast-talking radio announcer Bert Healy. He shines while hawking toothpaste and singing โYouโre Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile.โ Valencia has a joy that goes beyond putting on a good face for the audience. Watch for him in the years ahead.
“Annie” continues at Roger Rocka’s Dinner Theatre in Fresno’s Tower District through September 20th.ย



Jeanie McKelvey
I believe thatโs the original dress that Lily St Regis wore in the first production! Itโs memorable too.
Denise Elizabeth Morris
I am curious to know… I went to see Campbell’s close on opening night it was wondering if you were going to go see that cast?